Q&A: The Legality of Surveillance

Q. I’d like to get the opinions of legal experts regarding boards that use the surveillance system to spy on residents they dislike, attempting to “catch” them at some behavior which may be against the building rules. So is it legal to spy on residents at all? If so, is it legal to spy on certain people and not others? And what are legal experts’ opinions of board members soliciting staff to make complaints about certain specific individuals?

                                          —Feeling Watched

A. “In general,” says Gital Dodelson, an attorney for the Red Bank firm of Giordano Halleran & Ciesla, “video surveillance in public areas is permissible in New Jersey. However, New Jersey’s video recording laws prohibit cameras in specific locations, including locker rooms, restrooms, and other areas in which a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy. In addition, the federal ‘Wiretapping Law’ (enforced by the state of New Jersey) makes it illegal to record conversations electronically without the consent of at least one party.

“Therefore, a condominium or homeowners’ association may install video surveillance (without audio) within public areas, so long as the surveillance does not intrude on those areas in which a person has a reasonable expectation of privacy (such as the locker rooms or restrooms in a clubhouse).

“However, all associations are subject to the specific governing documents of the community (e.g., the Master Deed or Declaration, Bylaws and Certificate of Incorporation). To the extent such governing documents prohibit surveillance cameras or other similar equipment, the association would be prohibited from implementing such measures without an amendment to the governing documents.

Read More...

Related Articles

Q&A: Changing the Rules to Benefit a Board Member

Q&A: Changing the Rules to Benefit a Board Member

Q&A: Saving Our Super’s Job

Q&A: Saving Our Super’s Job

Q&A: Is a Board Allowed to Share Personal Information With Non-Owners?

Q&A: Is a Board Allowed to Share Personal Information With Non-Owners?

Q&A: When the HOA Is Not Doing Its Duty

Q&A: When the HOA Is Not Doing Its Duty

‘Problem’ Board Members

The Art of Working With Challenging People

Business Corporation Law Versus Conflicts of Interest

How Both Impact Boards